Showing posts with label Lancaster Unity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lancaster Unity. Show all posts

Friday, 12 December 2008

Disappointment for enemies of our Union Brotherhood

On December 04, 2008 the misnamed 'Lancaster Unity' site published a report on the investigation of the Certification Office into the financial affairs of the Solidarity Trade Union. This was entitled 'An Inspector calls' (how original, see my previous report of the same title!). The investigation was a result of complaints made by 'Lancaster Unity', Searchlight and a disgruntled former official, Clive Potter.



It is worth taking a look at their partisan and inaccurate account. It is important to understand the mind-set of those who are paid to attack those seeking to provide an alternative to the established Unions.



LU refer to the "fake fascist Solidarity 'trade union'." Let's consider this.



Why 'fake? Solidarity represents members at disciplinary and grievance hearings. It represents them before professional bodies. It represents them in tribunal proceedings. As a percentage a higher number of our membership call on our help than most establishment Unions. A number of cases involve political discrimination but most are bread and butter Union issues.
Why 'fascist'? Solidarity recruits from all political persuasions and none. It has not barred anyone on political grounds. We refuse to discriminate in this way. The function of a Trade Union is to represent workers in disputes with the bosses. There is simply no justification for this smear but it is typical of the Stalinist tactics pursued by Lancaster Unity. In fact by misapplying the term they both devalue it and discredit themselves.



LU go on:



"It is a matter of record that the BNP was obliged to hijack its own front-group from its founders to save the skin of Patrick Harrington and to keep it on a course favoured by the BNP, which led to the simultaneous existence of two Solidarity's - the legally constituted version led by Clive Potter and Tim Hawke, and the BNP-dominated hijacked version, led by Adam Walker and Patrick Harrington."



Well no, it's not a matter of record. Our members decide who run Solidarity, not the BNP, LU or anyone else. They have made their views clear at General Meetings and in elections. Those who joined the Union early ('founders' as both Mr Potter and LU like to call them) have no more rights than any other member. I note that during the first year of the Union very little was done. I note also that the Constitution was very badly drafted and has had to have substantial revision.
There have never been "two Solidarity's" outside the imagination of those who write for LU. It is interesting to note that LU are backing Potter and Hawke and declaring them to be the "legally constituted version".



For there to be two Solidarity's there would have to be two organisations meeting the legal requirements imposed on Trade Unions. There is and only ever has been one. Only we have submitted accounts to the CO. Only we have held elections (as required by law). Only we held an Annual Conference. Hawke has lost interest and gone to infiltrate the Steadfast Trust instead. Potter sends ranting letters to the CO still but he is a busted flush. Solidarity is firmly under the control of its elected Executive and it will stay that way. The traitors, agents and their dupes have failed and the members with a united and determined leadership have won.



Speaking of the vexatious and unfounded complaints against Solidarity LU state:-
"It was only in May of this year that the trade union Certification Office took up numerous complaints regarding irregularities in the financial affairs of Solidarity, all of them lodged by Clive Potter, Tim Hawke and Bill McLinden, with additional material supplied by Lancaster Unity and Searchlight - neither of which organisations, I must emphasise, has been in contact with, or has in any way supported Messrs Potter, Hawke and McLinden."



Not supported them or been in contact? Yeah, right.



LU then turn to making ill-informed comments about aspects of the report:-



"The inspector's looming visit to Edinburgh seems to have galvanised Patrick Harrington, since, being unable to provide an original receipt for £39 in printing expenses, he apparently did have a copy of the same "certified as an authentic copy by an Edinburgh solicitor". Since it is highly unlikely that the Edinburgh solicitor was present when Harrington came into possession of the original (and we are assuming there ever was an original) and also present when it was copied by whatever means, we can only presume that Harrington took himself off to this solicitor, copied receipt in hand, and swore to its authenticity."



In fact a certified copy is not a copy of a copy but a copy of the original. The solicitor takes a copy of the original and certifies that they have seen it. Their presumption is therefore quite wrong.
The CO asked for copies of the original receipts to be mailed to them, Solidarity took the original receipts to a solicitor who made a copy and certified them so that union could retain the original receipts, and the CO could have certified copies for their investigation. An original receipt was later mislaid, but because certified copies of all original receipts had been supplied to the CO, there was a second copy.



LU have clearly read the sections of the report relating to PayPal transactions. I was able to show that money from PayPal had been transferred to Union bank accounts or used to pay legitimate Union expenses (such as web hosting). Mr Walker, acting for the CO, notes that Mr Potter accused me of personal fraud. He found no evidence to substantiate this serious accusation. I was cleared by an independent investigation. You might expect Mr Potter to apologise and beg forgiveness but he continues his attacks on the Brotherhood. A very unwise course he may yet find.

"Section 21 deals with Potter's allegation that Harrington made two unauthorised withdrawals from Solidarity's HSBC account, and one unauthorised transfer from its HSBC Business Money Manager Account into its HSBC community account in September 2007."



I was able to show that these withdrawals were authorised by the Solidarity Executive chosen at the Special Meeting of the membership. The money withdrawn was transferred to a new Union bank account and used to pay the accountant. This was all proved to the satisfaction of the CO. All of my actions were undertaken to ensure that the Union was able to continue to provide services to its members and carry out normal activities despite the attempts of traitors, agents and their dupes to disrupt that work.

LU then go through the section of the report concerning claims that cheque payments were not authorised. It is not common practice in most organisations for every day-to-day expense to be approved. In the Union at the time only expenditure over £200 required such authorisation. Clearly the small amounts of money expended fell well below that level. They were not cheques written to me personally but to members of the Union for legitimate expenses.



"The second payment was in respect of expenses claimed by a Solidarity member who had travelled to London from Swansea for the Union's AGM. He had not been able to find the Solidarity steward redirecting members to the AGM location and had been very angry about his wasted journey. Mr Harrington stated that he and Mr Potter had agreed to pay the rail and tube fares and subsistence as a gesture of good will. Mr Potter does not dispute that he agreed that this payment be made. He alleges however, that it was paid in cash out of a cash donation made to Solidarity at the AGM. Mr Harrington denies this."



Potter did make such an allegation. There are two obvious points. How would I have paid the member from Swansea on the day of the AGM as he never met up with us (that was why we were paying him!). Also I was in the company of a members from around 7am in the morning to around 12 midnight. It was a very busy day. I could get the member concerned to swear an affidavit as to the payment if need be and I can subpoena the bank for the cheque. Once again those seeking to make false allegations against me never had any prospect of success. The CO were satisfied that there was no wrong-doing.



LU then raise regular payments made for expenses.



"Most curiously of all, Harrington was paid £75 per month in expenses, but not - as you would suppose - into an account in his own name. For his own mysterious reasons Harrington had the expenses paid into an account in the name of P.A. Sharp, his briefly famous ex-wife. This does not seem to us to accord with the behaviour of real general secretaries of real trade unions. Why, and from whom, did Harrington wish to obscure the fact that he was in receipt of £75 in expenses each month? Is this still his regular practice?"



There were three payments of £75 paid into my account for transfer into petty cash for expenses. All is recorded and backed by receipts in Union accounts. Note I say that the money was put into my account for transfer. P A Sharp stands for Patrick Antony. Sharp was my married name. I pay my union subs from the same account. The accusation that I wished to "obscure the fact that he was in receipt of £75 of expenses" is false. I received no income as such but simply facilitated a transfer of funds. It is not 'curious' at all that we use petty cash. Most organisations do.



LU spend some time attacking the Union PR firm Accentuate. They speculate as to whether the CO thinks that Accentuate provide good value for money in their work for the Union. Accentuate provide regular reports to the Executive. Additionally, Union members were provided with a report and the opportunity to ask questions of Graham Williamson of Accentuate at our last Annual Conference.



Our Union prefers to engage those sympathetic to the aims of the Union and whose background we know well. This is not 'corruption' in any standard definition of the term. It is pragmatic and responsible.



The Executive and membership of Solidarity are currently very happy with the work provided. As long as that remains the case the firm will continue to be engaged by us.

LU turn: to the appointment of auditors in 2006:-



"In the matter of Solidarity's 2006 accounts, Clive Potter made the incontrovertible allegation that Harrington (strangely, for a supposed trade union general secretary) breached the union's Rule 15 in the appointment of "close friends and political allies", Messrs Lindley and Smith, as auditors."

Mr Potter complained that the Auditors had not been appointed by the Executive. At the same time he maintained that at no time did the Executive vote or express a view on the subject. Odd, given that Mr Potter and Mr Hawke would both have been aware of the need to arrange Auditors. This oddity is explained by the fact that their account is entirely mendacious. I was asked to arrange Auditors and I did. It only became an issue when Mr Potter decided to launch a Palace Coup.



Those appointed did a professional job and made no charge to the Union. I believe that those appointed were acceptable to our members. I would like to thank both Mr Lindley and Mr Smith for that work and express contempt for those who have sought to call their integrity into question here.



The allegation made by Potter (like all the others) wasn't against me but against the Union. Mr Potter never raised rule 15 of the Constitution in any email or verbally. Nor did Mr Hawke. Following collective responsiblility Mr Potter and Mr Hawke were as responsible for the oversight as I was. That Potter sought to raise complaints about it is therefore odd. The Union complied with the law, however.



The CO states "those bringing the allegations that I have investigated were more concerned with progressing [the internal] power struggle than the actual issues relating to process and compliance that I have been called upon to investigate by my terms of reference".
It is interesting to note that all of those at that time within the Union making the complaints were personal friends and supporters of Clive Potter who stood to gain if they were able to unseat myself and the legitimate Executive.



But Lancaster Unity ask:-



"Quite how that applies to information supplied independently by Lancaster Unity and Searchlight is not clear in the slightest."



I question whether the complainants have acted independently. Certainly their aims and objectives overlap in this area. LU has explicitly made statements supportive of the Traitor, dupe or agent Clive Potter many times. They are scarcely a disinterested or impartial Party.They brought similar complaints in the same period. Nor is it clear why they would have any special knowledge as to the internal workings of our Union. As such what 'evidence' could they provide and where would they have obtained it? As outsiders where could they have obtained 'evidence' from?



LU are disappointed that the Certification Office did not rule on who should run the Solidarity Union but that is certainly not part of that role. I can quite see why LU would prefer us to be run by Potter and Co. an ineffective, lacklustre and suspect leadership but Solidarity is a membership organisation. It is for the members to decide who runs it and they have made their views clear. By making complaints against Solidarity even the supporters of Potter have implicitly accepted who runs it.



LU are disappointed that they have spent so much time, alongside the embittered and twisted Potter, attacking the Union to no avail. The Certification Office investigated all allegations thoroughly and have published a comprehensive report. The key allegations made against the Union were dismissed.

Gerard Walker for the Certification Office states:-



"My overall conclusions, having investigated the individual allegations, is that I have found no evidence of personal dishonesty or systematic maladministration of members' money".



The Certification Office acted professionally and fairly during the investigation. The Union co-operated throughout and has learned valuable lessons from the process. Those interested should read the whole report rather than subjective and partisan accounts from tainted and unreliable sources.

Monday, 2 June 2008

An Inspector Calls?

'Lancaster Unity' have published an interesting article:- Lancaster Unity: TU Certification Office investigating Solidarity

The infantile leftists at the LU blog have a lot to say about the Solidarity Union (little of it accurate). Let's take a look at their latest assertions and arguments.

They begin by reproducing the statement from the Certification Office announcing an enquiry into Solidarity. Then they state:-

"It is a very strange thing indeed that the supposed General Secretary of a supposed trade union only thinks it "possible" that the Certification Office is a "neutral party", as if he had no idea what the Certification Office existed for."

Really? Do they find it strange that some members of our Union doubt the neutrality of a State agency? A State agency which has been bombarded with letters from our Union rivals, traitors and political opponents seeking to pressurise them into closing our Union down. How odd of them! For the record, I still entertain the hope that the CO is neutral - time will tell whether I or the cynics are right. I fully expect that once presented with the evidence the CO will discount the many malicious and vexatious allegations which have been made against our independent Union.

'Lancaster Unity' then seek to question what services our Union provides. It is a matter of record that we have provided members with representation at various stages of grievance procedures, benefits appeals, disciplinary hearings, ACAS concilliation, and have put in cases on their behalf to Employment Tribunals. Our last case resulted in a negotiated settlement (including a confidentiality clause) to the benefit of a member who quit his job. To argue that we have only one case is inaccurate and childish. So far we have represented around twenty of our members in different respects. We have attended meetings at Astra Zenica, GNER, Cummings, Middlesbrough FC, Alliance and Leicester, County Durham and 'Harvey Nicks' to name a few. 'Lancaster Unity' may not like our Union for political reasons but there is little point in them making assertions which can be disproved with ease.

Next they state:-

"As we have seen in past articles, it is very far from being the "One Big Union" of Harrington's vaulting aspirations, having only 211 members (allegedly), and having stirred little interest among the BNP membership at which it aims itself. Its annual conference was a tawdry hole and corner affair hedged about with tight security, and attended by only 27 members - almost a third of those sitting on the Executive platform."

Solidarity continues to recruit. We announced the figure of 211 members some time ago. Each week more join. Members of the BNP join our Union because we are prepared to uphold their rights as well as others. We stand against discrimination on political grounds in the same way that we oppose discrimination on racial, sexual, religious or other grounds. It is true that only a tiny proportion of BNP members are also members of our Union. Those that are have, in many cases, been active Trade Unionists for many years.

All Solidarity meetings have "tight security". At our Annual Conference, held in Birmingham, threats were made by supporters of 'Lancaster Unity' to Hotel staff. This was very distressing for workers simply doing a job (many of them from ethnic minorities). 27 in attendance represents over 13 per cent of our membership. If that percentage figure remains the same as we grow I will be quite content. We have seven members of our Executive and they were all present. Next year the Executive will consider subsidising travel for those attending.

Then 'Lancaster Unity' turn to Mark Walker:-

"And, of course, it has taken on only one case since its inception, that of sacked teacher Mark Walker, a BNP man advised by the useless "fighting union" to find himself a lawyer specialising in employment law."

As I have already pointed out we have taken on over twenty cases - not one. Mark Walker has not been sacked (attention to detail please comrades!). He has been suspended on full-pay for over fourteen months now. It was only recently that the management investigation was completed. It is only now that we expect to move to a formal disciplinary. I represented Mark at the last meeting in May personally. I will continue to represent him at any future meetings. Our Union (alongside Civil Liberty) is paying for an Employment Lawyer for specific aspects of this complex case. It is not unusual for Trade Unions to utilise the services of lawyers! Many of our members know Mark and can ask him themselves whether he thinks the £1.25 a week we charge represents good value for money!

Wednesday, 30 April 2008

LUAF and David Kerr

Lancaster Unity scrapes the barrel by publishing comments designed to have a go at Ulster Nation editor and Solidarity EC member David Kerr' The anonymous poster does their best to smear David Kerr with the 'racist' tag. Here's the case for the prosecution followed by that of the defence...

Under David Kerr's leadership the Ulster Third Way is affiliated to the US-based Council of Conservative Citizens.

This is not true. U3W is not affiliated to the CofCC in any way. In response to an invitation Kerr did indeed address a meeting of the CofCC in 1997 in his capacity as Chairman of the now defunct Ulster Independence Movement. His acceptance of a speaking engagement should not be taken as an endorsement of everything in the CofCC's political platform. As for the verdict of the bunch of gougers styling themselves the Southern Poverty Law Center and the hysterical Ant-Defamation League: their allegations are not to be taken seriously. Against all evidence, the SPLC defames the 'neo-Confederate' League of the South' as a racist hate group. The League of the South and groups such as the Southern Party of Georgia are nothing of the kind and David Kerr is proud to stand alongside them in defence of common values.

Under David Kerr the Nation website carries links to the League of the South and the 'nazi BNP's fake cover groups such as Solidarity and Civil Liberty.'

David Kerr does not believe that the BNP is now a 'nazi' party and he believes strongly in the cause of Civil Liberty and free trade unions. Lancaster Unity's commentator doesn't seem to have noticed that the links page clearly carries a disclaimer to the effect that 'Apart from the Third Way sites, the presence of a link on this page should not be taken to imply any organisational link with the organisations or individuals behind those sites. A link is not a full endorsement of all or any of the political, historical or ideological positions taken by the publishers of such sites.' Some sites are useful for readers looking for good background on history and politics; Slugger O'Toole, N I Elections and Newshound. Some are good new sources for anti-war activists; antiwar.com and Americans Against World Empire. Some are good at exposing the risks of an all-powerful surveillance State; Privacy International and Civil Liberty. Lancaster Unity's narrow focus distorts the truth.

As for Solidarity being a 'front' for the BNP no matter how many times they repeat it this still will not be true!

Further, the Ulster Third Way website praises the racist and fascist book The Eleventh Hour by John Tyndall, the convicted neo-nazi terrorist and founder of the BNP 'In thoroughly recommending this book to all those looking for alternative political thinking'.

This really is a piece of dishonest distortion. Firstly this is a guest review written by the veteran British nationalist John Bean and is solely Mr Bean's opinion of the book. The Ulster Nation website has always encouraged debate and the exchange of ideas. A disclaimer on every page makes it clear that the views expressed in signed articles and reviews are solely those of the author. Mr Bean’s view of Tyndall's book is quite different from that of David Kerr. Mr Bean had his own criticisms too. The partial sentence quoted above concludes, 'I would make just two minor criticisms.' They are 'a certain amount of repetition' and 'he does use three words where he could get away with two.' Lancaster Unity's selective quotation by wresting the first part of this sentence from its context and the implied attribution of these opinions to David Kerr are without justification.

David Kerr has reviewed quite a few political books from the left field of the political spectrum. He thoroughly recommended Paul Foot's Who Framed Colin Wallace? to all Third Way supporters and also praised Mark Steel's Reasons to be Cheerful as an honest book. By Lancaster Unity's reckoning this 'links' Kerr with the Socialist Workers Party.

Digging deep in the archives of the Ulster Nation site, the Lancaster UAF correspondent has dug up an article written in January 1995 by David Kerr. At the time the ANC government of Nelson Mandela had been in power for a few months and there was a lot of apprehension about. Most people will admit to having been surprised by how well the ANC government did under Mandela after assuming power in 1994. This was by no means obvious at the time despite Lancaster Unity's 20-20 hindsight. Mandela's organisation did use terrorist methods against its enemies and - at times - innocent civilians. The ANC denied the right of the nations of Southern Africa to their own states. Similar strictures in the former and led to major conflict. It was not unreasonable to fear that something similar could have happened in 1995. Mugabe's was the malign template. Happily things never got quite that bad – so far – but it is far from being the paradise of rose-tinted leftist dreams.

Dagging about in the mid-nineties, the UAF correspondent digs up a 1996 article Living Alternatives – neither racism nor 'multiculturalism' to have another crack at Kerr. Where the critic falls down is that this discussion piece was not written by Kerr at all. It was written by another Third Way activist using the pen name 'John Jenkins'.

This article was written twelve years ago when racial attacks were indeed virtually unheard of but when organisations like NICEM were trying to justify their funding by exaggerating the severity and extent of such attacks. In the last four or five years there has been a genuine increase in such attacks: although even now the rate of such attacks is low in comparison to sectarian attacks across the religious divide. The idea was to argue for a 'living alternative' to outright racism and trendy multiculturalism. For 1996 this was quite groundbreaking as crude biological racism had still quite a strong following in nationalist circles at the time. Ultimately the Lancaster Unity correspondent is trying to force Ulster Third Way into a mould for which it is unsuitable.

Same old fascism. Same old racism – doesn't matter whether it's the BNP or Patrick Harrington and his Third Way, it's all the same.

Well, no. Lancaster Unity's definition of both fascism and racism is very elastic. Third Way is not the same as the BNP. The 2008 BNP is not the same as the 1982 BNP. Just as they elide fascism and nazism they like to portray all expressions of nationalist thinking as all the same. it's totally untrue, of course and as shown above, they will twist any article through selective quotation, perfect hindsight, projection of ideas and attitudes to explain what Third Way 'really' means. Opposition to mass migration does not mean opposition to non-whites. In fact the Third Way is open to members from all ethnic and faith backgrounds. It has clearly stated that it aims for a harmonious, multi-cultural society.

Wednesday, 9 April 2008

Theft is theft - even when it's intellectual property theft

Have you ever been in a pub and seen a loud drunk trying to start a fight and then when challenged seeking to involve and get back-up from his friends? I have and sometimes the friends are wise enough to stay out of things, other times they don't and the consequence is often that they end-up getting a good-kicking. I thought of this analogy when reading an entry entitled “Get stuffed Harrington!” on a supposed 'anti-fascist' blog.

It reported:-

“The Great Fantasist himself, the One Big Vast Huge Onion's farcical serial failure Patrick Harrington, is attempting to get Blogger to do the dirty legal work he's too afraid to do himself.He's complained that we used the photograph above from the One Big Vast Huge Onion's website and therefore breached his copyright.”

This was in response to a complaint I filed with Blogger (owned by Google) regarding infringment of copyright. Norfolk Unity had been warned previously that action would be taken if they did not respect copyright and could at that stage have quietly removed the offending image. That isn't exactly their style, however.

Instead they responded by stating:-

“Anyway, Harrington's a bit on the late side. That photo has already appeared on several other internet sites, and though we can't be sure, we have a feeling it's about to appear on many more.We're not taking it down, and we're not removing the post.As far as we're concerned, loser Harrington can take a running jump off the end of the Britannia Pier. We're Norfolk Unity, not Clive Potter or Tim Hawke - and we bite back.”

The picture was then posted on a number of associated sites. We were very intimidated! It also meant that we had to complain about all these other sites which have taken a hostile attitude to the Solidarity Brotherhood!

The result was that the image (and sometimes pages) from the following sites were removed:-

http://kirkunity.blogspot.com/2008/03/solidarity-and-mysteries-of-copyright.html
http://norfolkunity.blogspot.com/2008/03/get-stuffed-harrington.html
http://lancasteruaf.blogspot.com/2007/12/bnp-ballerina-provokes-new-storm.html
http://lancasteruaf.blogspot.com/2008/03/huge-growth-for-bnps-one-big-union.html
http://birminghamunity.blogspot.com/2008/03/norfolk-unity-tells-hypocrite.html
http://kirkunity.blogspot.com/2008/03/solidarity-and-mysteries-of-copyright.html
http://antifascistnetwork.blogspot.com/2008/03/solidarity-and-mysteries-of-copyright.html http://norfolkunity.blogspot.com/2008/03/huge-growth-for-bnps-one-big-union.html

The end result was that not only Norfolk Unity but the other infantile leftist sites have made themselves appear foolish. Our Union will enforce Copyright and deal with any infringement of our legal rights. If you sign-up to the terms and conditions of American servers and companies you shouldn't complain when we refer to US law in our complaints. That shouldn't be taken to mean, however, that we will not take action in other or multiple juristictions.

Tuesday, 1 April 2008

Hear the truth before you read the lies

This blog has been created on the orders of Patrick Harrington. Patrick Harrington is the General Secretary of the Solidarity Trades Union and a Director of the Third Way think-tank. He became concerned at the disinformation being spread by some blogs of the infantile left and felt that their arguments and reactionary positions needed to be analysed, deconstructed and replied to. This blog will answer all those bloggers who adopt positions which are dishonest and reactionary and not just Lancaster Unity.